The Inside Swing

Best Private Golf Courses in New York

The top 5 private and members-only golf courses in New York, ranked by our editorial team for 2026.

1

New York, New York · William Flynn (1931) · 18 holes · Par 70 · 7,445 yards

One of the five founding member clubs of the USGA, Shinnecock Hills is among the most revered courses on the planet. The windswept links-inspired layout on the eastern end of Long Island has hosted five U.S. Opens and embodies the essence of American championship golf.

Five-time U.S. Open hostFounding USGA member clubLinks-inspired Long Island masterpiece
Green Fee: Members Only Rating: 5/5
2

New York, New York · A.W. Tillinghast (1923) · 18 holes · Par 72 · 7,477 yards

Host of six U.S. Opens including the 2020 championship, Winged Foot West is one of Tillinghast's greatest achievements. The demanding par-72 in Mamaroneck features some of the most complex green surfaces in the game.

Six-time U.S. Open hostTillinghast's finest workLegendary green complexes
Green Fee: Members Only Rating: 4.9/5
3

New York, New York · Charles Blair Macdonald (1911) · 18 holes · Par 72 · 6,779 yards

Founded by C.B. Macdonald, the father of American golf architecture, National Golf Links is a template course that inspired generations of designers. The links-style layout on the Peconic Bay in Southampton features Macdonald's famous renditions of classic British holes including the Redan, Alps, and Cape.

C.B. Macdonald's template masterpiecePeconic Bay links settingInspired generations of American golf architecture
Green Fee: Members Only Rating: 4.9/5
4

New York, New York · Willie Park Jr. / Jack Nicklaus (restored) (1891) · 18 holes · Par 72 · 6,621 yards

One of the oldest clubs in America, Maidstone occupies a spectacular oceanfront setting in East Hampton with Atlantic dunes, ocean views, and Hook Pond. The Willie Park Jr. design has been sensitively updated while maintaining its raw, natural character that makes it feel closer to Scotland than the Hamptons.

Spectacular East Hampton oceanfrontAmong the oldest clubs in AmericaScottish-style dunes and ocean setting
Green Fee: Members Only Rating: 4.7/5
5

New York, New York · Devereux Emmet / Walter Travis (1899) · 18 holes · Par 73 · 6,840 yards

One of the finest Golden Age courses on Long Island, Garden City Golf Club features flat, windswept terrain reminiscent of British links golf. The Emmet/Travis design rewards ground-game creativity and has hosted numerous USGA amateur championships.

Golden Age links-style designHosted multiple USGA championshipsFlat windswept terrain rewards ground game
Green Fee: Members Only Rating: 4.6/5

More New York Golf

Frequently Asked Questions

How many private and members-only golf courses are in New York?
We've identified 5 top-rated private and members-only courses in New York. The state has many more total courses, but these represent the best options for visiting golfers.
What is the best private and members-only course in New York?
Shinnecock Hills Golf Club (William Flynn, 1931) is our top-ranked private and members-only course in New York with a 5 rating.

Stay in the Loop

Get weekly rankings updates, destination guides, and insider tips delivered to your inbox.