The Inside Swing

Best Private Golf Courses in Indiana

The top 4 private and members-only golf courses in Indiana, ranked by our editorial team for 2026.

1

Carmel, Indiana · Pete Dye (1964) · 18 holes · Par 72 · 7,516 yards

Host of the 1991 PGA Championship won by John Daly and the 2012 BMW Championship, Crooked Stick is Pete Dye's longtime home club and one of his most personal designs. The layout through rolling central Indiana terrain features Dye's bold shaping, strategic water hazards, and railroad-tie bulkheads.

1991 PGA Championship and 2012 BMW Championship hostPete Dye's personal home clubBold Dye shaping through rolling Indiana terrain
Green Fee: Members Only Rating: 4.8/5
2

Newburgh, Indiana · Tom Fazio (1998) · 18 holes · Par 72 · 7,209 yards

A Tom Fazio design in southern Indiana, Victoria National is consistently ranked as the best course in the state. The stunning layout winds through ravines, ridges, and hardwood forest along a former Ohio River flood plain with bold Fazio shaping and tournament-quality conditioning.

Consistently ranked #1 course in IndianaTom Fazio design through dramatic ravinesFormer Ohio River flood plain terrain
Green Fee: Members Only Rating: 4.7/5
3

Bridgeport, Indiana · Pete Dye (2003) · 18 holes · Par 72 · 7,349 yards

Built on a former coal mine, Pete Dye Golf Club is one of the architect's most ambitious and dramatic designs. The reclaimed terrain features 100-foot elevation changes, dramatic ravines, and bold shaping that transforms industrial wasteland into one of the most visually striking courses in America.

Built on reclaimed coal mine terrain100-foot elevation changes and dramatic ravinesAmong Pete Dye's most ambitious designs
Green Fee: Members Only Rating: 4.6/5
4

Indianapolis, Indiana · William H. Diddel (1924) · 18 holes · Par 72 · 6,800 yards

One of Indianapolis's most respected private clubs, Broadmoor was designed by noted Indiana architect William Diddel in 1924. The mature parkland layout features tree-lined fairways, subtle green complexes, and a classic Midwestern character that has been carefully preserved through multiple sensitive renovations.

William Diddel classic 1924 designOne of Indianapolis's most respected private clubsClassic Midwestern parkland character
Green Fee: Members Only Rating: 4.4/5

More Indiana Golf

Frequently Asked Questions

How many private and members-only golf courses are in Indiana?
We've identified 4 top-rated private and members-only courses in Indiana. The state has many more total courses, but these represent the best options for visiting golfers.
What is the best private and members-only course in Indiana?
Crooked Stick Golf Club (Pete Dye, 1964) is our top-ranked private and members-only course in Indiana with a 4.8 rating.

Stay in the Loop

Get weekly rankings updates, destination guides, and insider tips delivered to your inbox.